Aussie
>
Property
>
New South Wales
>
Maitland
>
Rutherford
>

5 First Ave, Rutherford NSW 2320

5 First Ave, Rutherford NSW 2320

1 / 11

View floor plan

NEW

Review the contract of sale using AI

For sale

$775,000

5 First Ave, Rutherford, NSW 2320

3

1

1

758.8m²

106m²

•

house - house

Map of 5 First Ave, Rutherford NSW 2320, Rutherford, New South Wales

Property Description

Listed on 25 Mar 2026

Set behind a welcoming façade and offering that unmistakable sense of solid craftsmanship, this immaculately maintained brick and tile home delivers the perfect blend of retro charm and everyday functionality. Neat as a pin and lovingly preserved, it presents an outstanding opportunity for first home buyers looking to enter the market with confidence, as well as savvy investors seeking a ready-made addition to their portfolio. With a tenant already in place on a periodic lease, the home provides immediate rental return from day one, while still allowing flexibility for future plans. Step inside and you’re greeted by wide, spacious hallways that instantly create a feeling of openness, connecting a separate formal lounge room and three well-proportioned bedrooms. As you move further through the home, a dedicated dining area flows seamlessly into the updated kitchen, thoughtfully positioned for easy meal preparation and entertaining. A second, generously sized living zone at the rear of the home adds incredible versatility, offering families multiple spaces to relax, unwind or come together – a layout that is far more expansive than first impressions suggest. All year round comfort is also provided by split system reverse cycle air conditioning. Outdoors, the property continues to impress with a well-kept, fully fenced yard and the added bonus of a large workshop or storage shed, which could easily double as a covered entertaining area. Practicality has also been carefully considered, with accessibility features including external ramps and internal railings, making the home suitable for a wide range of buyers and lifestyles. Positioned within easy reach of everyday essentials, you’ll enjoy the convenience of being just a short stroll or quick drive to local shops, schools and transport, and only approximately five minutes to Maitland CBD. Offering immediate comfort, long-term potential and instant income, this is a smart, well-rounded opportunity that ticks all the right boxes for both home buyers and investors alike. This property is proudly marketed by The Mick Haggarty Team. Contact 0408 021 921 or 4933 5544 for further information or to arrange a private inspection. First National Maitland – We Put You First. Disclaimer: All information provided is from sources we believe to be reliable; however, we cannot guarantee its accuracy, and prospective buyers should conduct their own enquiries.

Estimated value

Based on comparable sales, past sales and available property data

Property valuation, estimate, range and confidence score

Calculate property value

Rental income estimate and range

Calculate rental estimate

Property history

A breakdown of how regularly this property entered and exited the market for sale or lease.

Sold
Apr 2026

$775,000

Listed for sale
Mar 2026

$775,000

Rental
Nov 2019

$420 PER WEEK

Listed for sale
Oct 2019

Contact Agent

Median house price trends

Comparing the price trend of houses in Rutherford against the state of New South Wales over the last 4 years. Source: Cotality

Comparable properties

See what similar properties in the area are selling and listed for.

Aussie mobile app icon

Get the Aussie app

Unlock property insights, track your equity and maximise home ownership with Aussie.

Market activity

A snapshot of how quickly properties are selling in the area and how many are currently available.

16 Days

House median days on market

26 Days

Unit median days on market

355 Properties

Sold in last 12 months

53 Properties

Available in the last month

Rutherford residents

Key characteristics of the residents in the area, view the full breakdown of the suburb here.

Under 18

Is the most common age range

Mortgaged Owners

Most common occupant type

Families

Most common household profile

Technicians and Trades Workers

Most common occupation

Detached Houses

Most common property type

Buyers Agent

Find your perfect property with our buyer's agents

Streamline the home buying process, let us search over 11 million properties, analyse suburbs and expertly negotiate for you.

Learn More

Nearby education

Schooling and educational options in the area, for all ages.

Rutherford Public School

K - Yr 6

Government

St Paul's Primary School

K - Yr 6

Catholic

Get a wider view

Widen your research to learn about the suburb, council or state that this property belongs to.

Rutherford

View the suburb data

Maitland

View the council data

New South Wales

Get a view of the whole state

Explore surrounding suburbs

Learn about neighbouring suburbs to see if they are better suited to your budget or lifestyle.

Median House: $913,076

Median Unit: $702,776

Median House: $894,091

Median Unit: $627,056

Median House: $871,018

Median Unit: $562,229

Median House: $1,051,587

Median Unit: $637,383

Median House: $700,789

Median Unit: $548,334

Median House: $996,995

Median Unit: N/A

Median House: $1,508,367

Median Unit: N/A

Median House: $703,462

Median Unit: $515,578

Median House: $1,445,835

Median Unit: $646,717

Frequently asked questions

The property at 5 First Ave includes 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom and parking for 1 car.

5 First Ave in Rutherford has a land size of approximately 758.8 square metres and an internal floor area of around 106 square metres.

5 First Ave in Rutherford, New South Wales, is close to local schools such as Rutherford Public School, St Paul's Primary School and Rutherford Technology High School

As of 4/1/2026, the property at 5 First Ave is recorded as sold.

Interested in 5 First Ave, Rutherford NSW 2320?

Have property questions?

Evaluate the best mortgage offers and calculate your repayments.

Save time & money with a Buyer's Agent helping secure your property.