“There is no universally better pathway.”
That is the starting point for anyone weighing up salaried (PAYG) and self-employed broking. The right choice is the model that fits your needs now, gives you enough support to build momentum and can evolve as your goals change.
As Trent Kelly, Aussie’s National Manager of Network Growth puts it, “The right start is the model that fits your needs now, gives you enough support to build momentum and can evolve as your goals change.”
That means looking beyond the headline differences between PAYG and self-employment. The more useful questions are about the support available in the first six months, how you will learn to generate and convert business, what commitment and financial runway the model requires, and whether the pathway can grow with the broker and business you want to become.
For a new-to-industry broker, the first milestone is not simply completing a qualification. It is turning knowledge into action: learning the work, writing early deals, building confidence and establishing a repeatable way to serve clients.
“The Broker Academy is designed to get people on the tools and build early momentum — with an ambition of eight deals in eight weeks — but the important part is what sits around that: ongoing mentoring, structured touchpoints and access to the experience of the wider Aussie network,” Trent says.
Training should move a broker from theory to action. A strong network should provide scenario help, perspective and confidence as the broker’s needs change.
“You are learning by doing, without being left to work everything out alone,” says Trent.
PAYG is sometimes treated as a passive option: a salary, an established brand and an employer that will build the career for you.
That is not how the strongest PAYG brokers operate. They use the structure around them, but still take ownership of their activity, relationships and client base. Personal growth still follows personal effort.
“The PAYG misconception is that the employer or the brand will build the career for you,” Trent says. “The strongest PAYG brokers behave as though they are building their own business inside an established structure: they grow their client base, create relationships and take ownership of activity.”
Self-employment has its own misconception: that flexibility and freedom begin on day one.
“With self-employment, the misconception is that flexibility starts on day one,” Trent says. “Usually the early stage takes capital, runway and a serious investment of time. It is very difficult to treat it as a part-time side hustle.”
Self-employed should not mean unsupported. A strong group can provide systems, specialists and peers, not just a single mentor. The model may change, but commitment and support still matter in either pathway.
Do not choose only for today. Choose a model that can evolve with you.
Start with the brand and customer proposition you will be proud to take to market. Then look closely at the support model and the pathway in front of you. Ask what help is genuinely available during the first six months, what the day-to-day expectations are, how clients and leads are generated, and what responsibility you will have for creating business.
You should also understand the support available across training, mentoring, compliance, technology, marketing and scenarios. Look closely at the economics, capital requirements, obligations and ownership arrangements. Finally, ask what credible next step exists if your ambitions change, whether that means greater responsibility, a different operating model or business ownership.
“The question is not only, ‘Will this get me started?’” Trent says. “It is also, ‘Will this still fit the broker and business I want to become?’”
PAYG can be a strong option for someone who values predictable early income and wants to build capability within an established structure.
It may be the right fit if you need more certainty while learning the fundamentals, want structured training and coaching, are still developing your network and confidence in client conversations, or prefer to learn the business before taking on the full responsibility of ownership.
PAYG is not a shortcut around the work. You still need to get on the tools, speak to people, follow up and use the support available. The strongest PAYG brokers behave as though they are building their own business inside an established structure.
For many brokers, PAYG can also be a valuable stage in a longer journey. It can provide a foundation before moving into a different operating model or business ownership later.
It is also common to transition into self-employment later. As Trent explains, “PAYG can be an excellent place to learn, and many strong PAYG brokers later transition.” The issue with PAYG is that this transition happens in accordance with the employer’s timeline, not the brokers, potentially limiting the growth of the broker in the first few years.
Self-employment may suit someone who is ready to take greater responsibility for building a business and is comfortable with a less predictable early income.
It can be a fit if you have the financial runway to manage the early ramp, are prepared to commit properly rather than treat broking as a side hustle, want a more direct link between the value you create and the opportunity available to you, and are motivated by control, ownership and long-term upside.
It also requires a willingness to self-generate, build relationships and follow through consistently. Self-employment can offer more control, but the freedom is earned after the foundations are built. Income variability, business responsibility and the need to create momentum are part of the decision.
The upside should never be presented as guaranteed. The right question is whether the potential ownership and growth fit your finances, working style, network and long-term goals.
Your first model does not have to define your entire career.
Some brokers start in PAYG to build capability, confidence and a client base before transitioning into self-employment or another form of ownership. Others know from the beginning that they want to build a business and are prepared to accept the learning curve.
When comparing opportunities, ask what happens if your ambitions change. Is there a credible next step toward greater responsibility, a different operating model or business ownership? The answer can be just as important as the starting offer.
The best way to compare PAYG and self-employed broking is to look at the pathway through your own numbers, goals and circumstances.
Explore your earning potential, ramp timeline and growth scenarios with Aussie, then choose the model that gives you the right foundation for the future you want to build.
Back to top
We acknowledge the Traditional Owners of the many lands where we live and work and pay our respects to Elders past, present and emerging. We celebrate the stories, culture and traditions of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Elders of all communities from the many lands where we live, work and gather.
© 2026 Lendi Group Distribution Pty Ltd ABN 27 105 265 861 Australian Credit Licence 246786. The Lendi Group Pty Ltd, which is the ultimate holding company of the Aussie and Lendi businesses is owned by numerous shareholders including; banks such as CBA, ANZ and Macquarie Bank, the Lendi founders and employees, and a number of Australian institutional investors and sophisticated investors including UniSuper.