How buying your second home is different to buying your first

Buying again gives you more levers to pull and chances to get caught out. It's not just about how much you can borrow.

13 June 2025

Claire Montejo

A picture of a newly purchased property.

While a lot of property press focuses on first timers, second (or third, or fourth) home buyers are a major force in the property market right now.

According to CoreLogic, buyers purchasing their second or subsequent property consistently make up nearly half of all monthly home loan activity. Meaning, around 48% of borrowing for home purchases comes from people who’ve already done it before.

Whether it’s a move for more space, a better school zone, or a lifestyle upgrade, second-home buyers are behind much of Australia’s housing activity and the conditions to buy again are ripe.

CoreLogic's April 2025 Housing Chart Pack revealed national home values have increased by 39.1% over the past five years, adding approximately $230,000 to the median dwelling value and exponentially boosting owner’s borrowing power in the form of equity.

But it’s not all green lights: the numbers are bigger, the decisions heavier, you don't get the same government support as you did the first time, and when you’re tapping into your equity, there's a lot at stake.

Let's unpack what's different about buying a second (or third) home and how to make your next move feel a whole lot easier.

Buying again? Here's why it's different.

Buying your second home isn't always easier; it's just different. You might feel more confident this time around, but the reality is that the financial pressure is greater, the support systems are fewer, and the decisions can feel even more complex. Here's what changes when you buy again and how the right strategy (and team) can make all the difference.

First-home buyer perks don't apply. Remember those helpful incentives when you bought your first home, like stamp duty discounts, First Home Owner Grant (FHOG), or deposit schemes? They were designed to help first-timers get a foot in the door, and they don't carry over.

This time, it's all on you. That could mean paying full stamp duty, covering all upfront costs, and leaning more on your savings or existing equity.

The financial load can feel heavier. Buying again usually means a bigger price tag. Whether you're upgrading, relocating or buying before you sell, the money side can get more complicated. This time, you might juggle a larger mortgage, existing debts (credit cards, car loans, school fees), family expenses, and bridging finance or dual property ownership.

You might also be interested in: Your house may not be worth what you think

You've got higher expectations (and that can stretch your budget). Your first home might have been about just getting in. A small place. A longer commute. A bit of DIY. But now? You know what you want and are unwilling to compromise on—things like a second bathroom, a bigger backyard, a better school zone, space for work and play, and a location that fits your lifestyle.

Those non-negotiables can bump up your budget, and that's where expert guidance can pay off.

Experience helps, but buying again still comes with pressure. Yes, you've done this before. But second-home buying often comes with more moving parts, bigger financial decisions, higher emotional stakes, and less time (especially with a growing family or job demands).

Let us do the heavy lifting.

The financial side of buying again: More options, more complexity

Buying your second home isn't just a rinse and repeat of your first. This time around, you're not starting from scratch; you're building on what you already own. Here's what can change the game and why talking to an Aussie Broker upfront is one of the smartest moves you can make.

Equity replaces savings, and it comes with conditions. Most second-time buyers lean on home equity instead of saving a fresh deposit. But unlocking that equity isn't as simple as it sounds. While it can help fund your next place, there are a few things to be aware of:

  • LVR limits: Most lenders want you to stay under an 80% loan-to-value ratio (LVR) to avoid Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI). That can shrink your usable equity.

  • Valuation gaps: Your lender may value your home more conservatively than expected, especially in changing markets.

  • Timing matters: If you're buying before you sell, your equity may be tied up until settlement unless you restructure early.

Trying to buy before you sell? Bridging loans and cross-collateralisation can help.

A bridging loan can help you close the gap, but it's not the right fit for everyone because:

  • You'll be managing two loans temporarily, which increases your risk.

  • Bridging loans often come with higher interest rates and tighter conditions.

  • If your current home sells for less or longer than expected, your budget could be squeezed.

Some lenders might also suggest cross-collateralising, using both properties as security for a single loan. While that can sound convenient, it can limit your flexibility, especially if you want to sell one property or restructure it later.

Bigger loans could also mean smarter lender selection. As your property goals grow, so do your borrowing needs. Once your loan size climbs, not all lenders play by the same rules. Some cap how much they'll lend based on property type or suburb.

Others also offer sharper rates for higher-value loans but apply stricter serviceability rules. If you own an investment property, how your rental income is assessed can vary wildly.

Why upgraders need a level head (and a clear plan)

When it's time to buy your second home, it’s likely that you know exactly what you want: more space, a second bathroom, maybe you’ll finally get that pool. But that clarity can bring emotion, and emotions can nudge you into decisions that cost more than expected if left unchecked.

Here are three common traps second-home buyers fall into and how to stay one step ahead.

Stretching too far for the "forever home." Pushing your budget too hard now can take its toll later. You might find that repayments stretch your cash flow, you're missing out on helpful features like offset or redraw, or you have less wriggle room for unexpected costs like renos, rate rises, or real-life expenses like school fees.

Start with what you can comfortably afford, not just what a lender approves. Use a Borrowing Power Calculator to run the numbers, then chat with your Aussie Broker about structuring your loan around your life, not the other way around.

Falling for "the one" too quickly. You've been scrolling for weeks. You've seen dozens of homes, and suddenly, there it is. Perfect backyard. Great kitchen. Instant spark. But getting swept up in the emotion of "the one" can sideline logic and fast.

Watch out for blowing past your max at auction, skipping important checks (building, pest, or contract clauses), or overlooking practical red flags like commute times or zoning issues.

Underestimating the real cost of a bigger home. A second home often comes with more features but also more bills: higher council rates and land tax, bigger maintenance and repair costs, larger energy bills from ducted air or pools, body corp fees in townhouses or apartments, or more space to furnish, clean, heat, and cool.

Buying your next home is a big step. It's exciting, but it's also easy to overextend if you don't have a plan. So, to keep things balanced, be clear on your budget, know your must-haves (and your nice-to-haves), understand the ongoing costs, and lean on seasoned experts for guidance.

You've already done this once and learned a lot along the way. Now, it's time to upgrade with confidence, clarity and a clear-eyed plan.

Are home loans making your head spin?

An Aussie Broker will take over the research and guide you in choosing the right home loan

Loan structuring: Why it matters more than ever

If you're still paying off your first home, adding a second loan means managing more debt and complexity. Lenders will look at the full picture, not just your income. Remember, your existing repayments will affect your borrowing capacity. You might also need to restructure your current loan to free up cash. Refinancing can help if it fits your long-term goals.

A report by The Australian in May 2025 noted that refinancing rose by 2.5% in the first quarter of this year, and by 22% over the past year, now making up almost 40% of mortgage applications. At Aussie, we compare your current loan with fresh options so you'll know exactly what your repayments and outcomes look like before you take the next step.

It's also best to watch for overlap periods and cash flow pressure. Many second-home buyers hit a cashflow crunch during the transition. That's because owning two properties, even briefly, comes with double the costs. You could be juggling bridging finance while your current place sells, two sets of council rates, insurance, or utility bills, and dual repayments until settlement lines up.

At Aussie, your broker will map out your timelines, flag overlap risks, and help you plan for every scenario so you're ready, not reactive.

Tapping into your equity through a loan top-up can also be a handy way to help fund your second home, but it's not always the cleanest path forward. You might encounter potential pitfalls like:

  • A top-up increases the debt tied to your current property.

  • It could push your loan over the LVR threshold and trigger LMI.

  • It might limit your flexibility for future moves or refinancing.

That's why second-home buyers often need a purpose-built loan, not just an add-on. This isn't a cut-and-paste of your first home loan. It's a whole new layer, and your strategy needs to reflect that. At Aussie, we:

  • Run repayment simulations across both properties.

  • Stress-test your budget with current rate scenarios.

  • Use the Aussie App to help you track repayments, equity, and timelines.

  • Tailor the loan structure to support your bigger goals, whether that's flexibility, future investments, or keeping life comfortable.

When your loan is set up right from the start, you can focus on what matters—finding the right home—without worrying about how to afford it.

Ready to buy again? Let's do it the smarter way.

Buying your second home isn't just about doing it all over again; it's about doing it better. You've got more equity, more experience, and more to consider. This time, the decisions are bigger. The financials are more complex. The stakes? They're higher. But you don't have to do it alone.

At Aussie, we help you take the guesswork out of your next move. From loan structuring to making the most of your equity, we'll guide you through the process with clarity and confidence. So, let's build a plan that works for you whether you're upsizing, relocating or unlocking the next chapter.

Start by talking to your local Aussie Broker. We'll help you see the full picture, stress-test your budget, and present what's possible so your next move feels less overwhelming and more exciting.

Buying your second home shouldn't feel harder. With the right support, it can feel smarter.

Chat with an Aussie Broker about your property plans

Back to top

Follow us

Twitter
LinkedIn
Facebook
Youtube
Instagram

Download the Aussie App

We acknowledge the Traditional Owners of the many lands where we live and work and pay our respects to Elders past, present and emerging. We celebrate the stories, culture and traditions of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Elders of all communities from the many lands where we live, work and gather.

© 2026 Lendi Group Distribution Pty Ltd ABN 27 105 265 861 Australian Credit Licence 246786. The Lendi Group Pty Ltd, which is the ultimate holding company of the Aussie and Lendi businesses is owned by numerous shareholders including; banks such as CBA, ANZ and Macquarie Bank, the Lendi founders and employees, and a number of Australian institutional investors and sophisticated investors including UniSuper.